Most Runners Guess Threshold – It’s Why They’re Stuck (Threshold Masterclass)

Download the Transcript

Find this podcast on:

(Or search 'Trees Dlake' in your favourite player)

I used to think I was training “smart” because my easy runs were clean and my weekly mileage looked responsible. I was consistent. I was patient. I was building this calm, reliable engine.

Then I walked into a sports testing lab expecting a pat on the back and got a wake-up call instead. My zone two was solid. VO₂ max was fine. But my threshold was narrow. Like, surprisingly narrow. The tester basically told me: you’ve got an engine, but you never taught it how to race.

That hit because it was true.

I had spent years building aerobic capacity, doing my slow easy miles, staying in zone two like a good student. But I had skipped the homework that actually makes race day make sense. And I had been wondering why my times had plateaued.

This is about that homework.

Listen to audio podcast below on your next run or watch the video above to learn more

What Lactate Threshold Actually Is

Lactate threshold is the point where your body produces more lactate than it can clear. Think of it like snow falling on warm ground. A few flakes, they melt. Too many too fast, they pile up. Threshold is that tipping point where effort is still sustainable but you’re right at the edge.

Here’s the thing most runners don’t know: lactate isn’t the villain. It’s actually a fuel source your body uses continuously, even when you’re sitting still reading this. The burn you feel when you go too hard isn’t lactate itself, it’s hydrogen ions, the byproduct of excess lactate your system can’t process fast enough. The real problem isn’t the lactate. It’s the overflow.

Threshold sits between zone two (easy aerobic, the long conversation zone) and VO2 max (the “I cannot do this much longer” zone). It’s the effort you can hold for roughly 45 to 60 minutes at maximum. For most runners, that translates to somewhere between current 10K and half marathon pace. Not goal pace. Not dream pace. Where you actually are right now.

Here’s the more interesting part: threshold isn’t just a pace. It’s a skill. And like any skill, it responds to consistent, structured practice, not random suffering. When you train at or just below threshold, your body gets better at clearing lactate, processing fuel more efficiently, and holding race form when everything starts to hurt. You’re teaching your system to take out the trash faster so you can stay in the sweet spot longer.

Zone two builds your aerobic engine. VO2 max adds the top-end power. But threshold is the bridge. It holds the whole system together. Without it, your training is like having a great car and never taking it on the highway.

The 3 Ways to Actually Train It

There’s a tendency to over-complicate this. Here are the three methods that actually work, ranked by how enjoyable they are to execute.

  • Progressive long runs are probably the most underused. Start easy, run most of the distance at a comfortable pace, then spend the final 15 to 20 minutes at threshold. This teaches your body to hold form and pace under fatigue, which is exactly what racing demands. It’s also less intimidating than a full tempo session because you ease into it.
  • Tempo intervals are my personal favorite. Instead of one long sustained threshold block that many runners dread, break it into segments of six to twelve minutes with short 30 to 75 second easy jogs in between. The key is keeping the recovery short enough that lactate stays elevated. You’re not resting, you’re pausing. The goal is quality time at threshold, not heroics. Think three by ten minutes, not one sufferfest.
  • Race-specific threshold work is where this all becomes concrete. Training for a marathon? Do longer threshold blocks, 20 to 25 minutes. Training for a 5K or 10K? Shorter repeats, six to eight minutes, but slightly faster. The point is to replicate what race day will ask of you. Not the finish line sprint. The sustained, controlled effort that gets you there.

One practical note: do these on flat terrain. Hills mess with pacing and heart rate in ways that make it hard to know if you’re actually at threshold or just fighting elevation. Track, flat road, back and forth on the same stretch. Boring by design. Effective by design.

Progress week to week. More reps, longer reps, or both. The goal a few weeks out from your race is to run most of what the race will demand at close to race pace, in training. When that’s possible, you’re ready.

“If your tempo run feels like a race, it’s not threshold.”

5 Mistakes That Make Threshold Training Useless

Most runners mess this up in predictable ways.

Mistake #1: Running it too fast

If your tempo run feels like a race, it isn’t threshold. You’ve slipped into VO2 max territory and you’re just burning fuel. The fix: dial it back until you can speak in short phrases but really don’t want to. Your brain should be fully functioning. That’s the zone.

Mistake #2: Skipping the aerobic base phase

Threshold work only has value if there’s something underneath it to build on. You can’t put icing on a cake that doesn’t exist yet. Zone two first, always.

Mistake #3: Doing threshold while exhausted

Sleep deprived, under-fueled, mentally wrecked… these states don’t produce adaptation. They produce bad movement patterns reinforced through repetition. Training equals rest plus work, not work plus more work.

Mistake #4: Calling everything threshold

Just because something is hard doesn’t make it threshold. 400 meter repeats at mile pace? That’s VO2 max work. A 20 minute all-out time trial? That’s a race. Threshold is controlled, repeatable, sustainably hard. It should look like rolling hills in your heart rate data, not the Rocky Mountains.

Mistake #5: Doing it every week forever

Threshold training isn’t a Tuesday habit. It’s a seasonal tool. Three months of solid progress, then a plateau. That plateau is your body telling you it’s adapted and needs a new stimulus. Periodize your training. Threshold gets its four to six weeks of focus before race season. So does VO2 max. So does recovery. Use it strategically.

“Threshold is the icing on the cake, but if the cake tastes horrendous, icing won’t save it.”

The Honest Truth About Finding Your Threshold (From Someone Who Tested Everything)

There are four common ways runners estimate their lactate threshold. Gut feel and zone two formulas like MAF (accuracy 4 out of 10, but practical and great for beginners). Online calculators using race data (accuracy around 6.5 out of 10, but built on assumptions about perfect pacing and ideal conditions). Field testing, a 20-minute hard time trial where you record average heart rate and multiply by 0.95 (accuracy 8 out of 10, repeatable, and free). And lab testing with actual blood lactate measurements (accuracy 9.5 out of 10, but expensive, hard to access, and hard to repeat).

I tried all four. Lab test, field test, race data calculators, and pure gut instinct from years of training. Here’s what genuinely surprised me: they all landed within a few beats per minute of each other. The gut feeling I had built through years of consistent training, tracking data, and racing had calibrated itself to the point where the lab just confirmed what I already knew.

That’s not a reason to skip testing. It’s a reason to understand what testing actually is. It’s feedback. The field test is probably your best starting point, free, accurate enough, and something you can repeat every month or two to track real progress. Use a chest strap or arm monitor, not your watch’s optical sensor. The optical sensors are not accurate enough for this kind of work.

One other thing worth knowing: the MAF formula (180 minus your age) is a solid starting point, but for many runners it sits 10 to 20 beats below their actual threshold. That means years of training in zone two can feel like the right approach while quietly leaving the most important training zone completely underdeveloped. I spent 13 years deep in MAF training. It built something real. But it also meant I had been accidentally avoiding the exact work that would have made me faster in races.

The Finish Line

Threshold training isn’t just about running faster. It’s about learning to operate at a sustained, uncomfortable intensity without falling apart. That’s a transferable skill. The ability to push into difficult territory, maintain form, and come out the other side having adapted, that’s not just a running thing.

Most of us live in the equivalent of zone two. Low stakes, comfortable, manageable. Or we spike into VO2 max moments, crisis, deadlines, big decisions, then crash. The threshold zone, that sustained, intentional pressure where you’re working hard but still in control, is underused in most areas of life too.

Learning to find and hold your threshold in running teaches you something. It teaches you that the uncomfortable middle ground isn’t something to sprint through or avoid. It’s where most of the actual growth happens. The tipping point you learn to sit just below in training becomes the ceiling you raise over time, in running and everything else.

That said, none of this matters if the basics are broken. Inconsistent mileage, poor sleep, easy runs that aren’t actually easy, these make threshold work just another stressor with no return. The icing only works if the cake is solid.

Build the base. Find your actual threshold. Train it like the skill it is. Repeat consistently. And every time you want to skip the uncomfortable middle and jump straight to the hard stuff or coast in the easy stuff, remember: the fulcrum is where the leverage lives.

Links & Learnings