Overtrained vs Undertrained – Which One Actually Wins on Race Day?

Download the Transcript

Find this podcast on:

(Or search 'Trees Dlake' in your favourite player)

Last month, I stood at the starting line of my marathon feeling totally cooked! I’d spent months piling on volume, chasing that elusive perfect training cycle, convinced that more was always better. By race day, my legs felt like concrete, and my excitement had evaporated somewhere around mile 18 (30km) of my final long run four weeks prior.

It got me thinking about a question that haunts every runner: Would you rather toe the line slightly overtrained or undertrained? It’s the kind of dilemma that keeps me awake the night before races, scrolling through Strava and second-guessing every training decision we’ve made in the past twelve weeks.

When More Becomes Less

Here’s the thing about overtraining. It’s seductive as hell. There’s something deeply satisfying about stacking workout upon workout, watching your weekly mileage climb like a stock market bubble. The logic feels bulletproof: if 50 miles per week is good, then 70 must be better, right?

But overtraining is like that friend who stays too long at the party. At first, they’re adding to the energy, but eventually they’re just making everyone uncomfortable and ruining the vibe. When you show up to a race overtrained, you’re not just carrying extra fatigue. You’re dragging the ghost of every missed recovery day behind you.

The Undertraining Advantage

There’s something about showing up slightly underprepared. I know that sounds counterintuitive, like bringing a butter knife to a gunfight, but hear me out. When you’re undertrained, you have headroom. You can dig deeper on race day because you haven’t already spent all your coins in training.

Think about it: would you rather discover your limits during a training run in week 14, or during the race itself when it actually matters? Undertraining keeps you in the game. It means you can string together multiple races without breaking down. It means life can happen—work deadlines, sick kids, travel—without derailing your entire season. It also means you’re not completely drained from training, which means you can actually push harder when the gun goes off.

Your Body Keeps the Books

Your body is like an unforgiving accountant. It keeps meticulous records of every training stress you’ve accumulated, and eventually, the bill comes due. The difference between overtraining and undertraining isn’t just about race day performance; it’s about what happens afterward.

When you overtrain, recovery isn’t just slow, it’s compound. You might be out for weeks or months, watching your fitness evaporate while you’re sidelined with burnout or injury. But when you undertrain slightly, you bounce back faster. You can race again sooner. You stay in the game longer.

This is especially crucial when life gets complicated. Being a human being with responsibilities means training will never be your only priority. Undertraining gives you flexibility. It means you can still show up and compete even when everything else is demanding your attention.

Playing the Long Game

Here’s what I’ve learned after years of swinging between these two extremes: the goal isn’t to peak for one race—it’s to build a sustainable relationship with running that enhances your entire life. When training becomes so consuming that you can’t eat vegetables, can’t travel, can’t be spontaneous, something has gone seriously wrong.

Running should make you more human, not less. It should give you energy for the rest of your life, not drain it all away. The sweet spot isn’t about finding perfect training; it’s about finding the approach that lets you keep showing up, year after year, without losing yourself in the process.

The ebb and flow between fitness and health, between pushing hard and backing off, between being race-ready and being life-ready; that’s not a bug in the system. That’s the feature. It’s what keeps this whole thing interesting and sustainable.

Finish Line Thoughts

If I had to choose, I’d rather show up undertrained. Not because it’s the optimal strategy for any single race, but because it’s the optimal strategy for a lifetime of racing. It keeps you hungry. It keeps you healthy. It keeps you in the game when the game really matters.

But maybe instead of asking whether to be overtrained or undertrained, we should be asking how to build training that’s resilient enough to handle life’s challenges while still allowing us to surprise ourselves on race day.

Because in the end, the best training plan isn’t the one that makes you fastest for twelve weeks. It’s the one you can stick with for twelve years. And that plan probably looks a lot more like controlled undertraining than it does like controlled overtraining.

The paradox isn’t really about training at all. It’s about learning to be comfortable with being slightly uncomfortable, and trusting that sometimes, less really is more.

Listen to audio podcast below on your next run or watch the video above to learn more

Links & Learnings